|
minimatt1967
Original Poster
7,879 posts
43 months
|
I heard on the news this morning that Joe Satriani is going to sue Coldplay for allegedly ripping his riff's on one of there tracks (the name of which slips my mind at this moment!), will he win?
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
|
|
whitechief
2,362 posts
32 months
|
Hmm, saw this on teletext this morning, will be interesting to see the outcome. Hope you the yoghurt knitting lentalist whingers don't win 
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
Nothing mentioned on satriani.com yet...
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
|
|
minipete
86 posts
40 months
|
I hope he wins,Coldplay are like U2 a bunch of tossers who think they are gods!
Sorry rant over!
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
 Not much of a rant but all Satch support gratefully received 
|
|
|
minimatt1967
Original Poster
7,879 posts
43 months
|
Good man, short but to the point, bang on
|
|
|
celticpilgrim
1,579 posts
80 months
|
Radio 5 played the Satch track over the Coldplay track.........
My money is on Satch!!!!
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
|
|
JonRB
28,895 posts
109 months
|
satchbot said: Bloody hate Coldplay  Love 'em or hate 'em, they're bloody nice chaps. Totally *not* full of themselves and seem pretty humble about the whole fame and success thing.
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
Exactly the same as Satch. I guess when you feel that your creation has been stolen then you must fight for it.
|
|
|
dibbly_dobbler
2,448 posts
34 months
|
Ok - love Joe (seen him live !) but sorry, I'm not thinking he's going to win this. Couple of notes the same but it's hardly a cover version is it !?
|
|
|
Evil Jack
1,076 posts
65 months
|
I'm a big fan of Satch, but it's just a coincidence IMO; a fairly standard chord progression which leads instinctively to that melody line.
|
|
|
ATG
11,423 posts
109 months
|
Two utterly banal "melodies" sound similar shocker. Why would anyone want to publicise that they had written that tosh?
|
|
|
FourWheelDrift
45,386 posts
121 months
|
Think about how many tunes are written in the world every day. Sooner or later you are going to get 2 songs with exactly the same basic notes. That's all they are, nothing spectacularly complicated, just something you could easily come with by humming it. Same type of situation as the Infinite monkey theorem which states "that a monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard for an infinite amount of time will almost surely type a given text, such as the complete works of William Shakespeare." Chris Martin, earlier. 
|
|
|
Twit
2,908 posts
101 months
|
Agree with the above.
It won't get anywhere near court, as it happens all the time. Can't see what the problem is really, everyone rips off everyone and its dead easy to write a song that you think is original and then find out its not afterwards.
|
|
|
elster
12,274 posts
47 months
|
Jees...I never realised Satriani was so skint.
|
|
|
Fire99
5,083 posts
66 months
|
elster said: Jees...I never realised Satriani was so skint. A touch cynical don't you think? Perhaps he's a little miffed that Coldplay are profiting alot of cash that may not have come from their own pen.. If (and i mean if) its true and i were Joe Satriani i would do the same.
|
|
|
satchbot
4,318 posts
46 months
|
Skint he isn't. Just protective of his creations as all musicians are.
|
|
