RE: Why the Lotus Elise still matters | PH Footnote

RE: Why the Lotus Elise still matters | PH Footnote

Wednesday 7th August

Why the Lotus Elise still matters | PH Footnote

Old but still gold, the Elise embodies what Lotus has always done well - and what it needs to do in the future, too



Given all that's been written, blogged, filmed, discussed and debated in the past 20-odd years, is there anything left to be said about the Lotus Elise? Well, yes, just about, what with the concept rapidly approaching 25 years old and Hethel's future looking decidedly different from its recent past. We all know the car's significance, its success is unparalleled in the firm's history and everyone will have their favourite derivative; with that in mind, and with one on loan for the PH parade at Silverstone Classic, there was no better time to reflect on the Elise's achievements.

There can't be many chassis that have persisted for so long with so few changes, a mark of how clever the initial idea was. The bonded, extruded aluminium tub was the perfect cake-and-eat-it solution for Lotus: light and stiff, so perfect for mounting sports car suspension on, while also relatively cheap to put into production - ideal for company which, at the time, was in whatever the straits are beyond dire.

All that you'll know already, but familiarity means the Elise doesn't always get top billing in a modern context. Much is made of the Alpine's A110's flyweight virtuosity, for example, but while it comes in a more usable package, there's also no escaping the fact it's still nearly 200kg heavier. A Porsche 718 Boxster GTS now has pretty much the same power of a late-90s 911 GT3, yet it's power-to-weight ratio remains inferior to the range-topping Elise. An M2 Competition makes another 160hp, yet is slower to 62mph (as a manual) than the Cup 250.


Furthermore, with the Evija on the way and a range renewal surely not far behind, it's critical that the Elise's deftness and lucidity (among other talents) aren't ignored or forgotten. Lotus is claiming that its new model will be the lightest of the ever-expanding 2,000hp EV hypercar club, but its proposed 1,600kg kerbweight has more in common with a Lotus Carlton than anything else to emerge from Norfolk in the past quarter of a century. Of course, the Evija will have all manner of physics-defying, torque-vectoring technology, but it's critical that the cars which will underpin the mainstream range keep the Elise's less-is-more mantra, too, even with the imminent advent of yet more mandatory technology.

Why? Because it makes for absolutely, undeniably brilliant sports cars. While nobody will ever claim that the Elise is the most capacious roadster around, and the Cup is probably firmer than is actually ideal for street use, the way the little Lotus charges down a road remains totally bewitching. It doesn't require steering mode changes for a greater sense of connection, because having access to such raw and unfiltered feedback is something you'd never want to change - apart from when parking, perhaps. But even that feels worth the trade-off. The Elise doesn't need damper adjustment on the fly, because the road set up for its Bilstein dampers delivers (mostly) sufficient suppleness to go with its vivid agility and scalpel-sharp response. This Elise is desperately close to being a bonafide Lotus Cup Europe race car, yet can still make liveable company on the road. (Don't forget, too, that a Sport 220 is still available for the less dedicated/deranged.)


Point is that, while some delicacy will have been lost from earlier, purer Elise iterations, the Cup shows how a simple yet clever piece of automotive engineering, enhanced and evolved over the years, can still deliver as a fantastic driver's car. Having as much power as a 330d but a kerbweight comfortably under a tonne means enormous performance; the feeling that comes with lightweight cars and chunky power outputs one of being caught in the breeze and hurled down the road, yet still in total control as the driver. A manual this tactile, that looks this good and works so well - especially with memory of Lotus's stringy shift past - doesn't need replacing. Dimensions that allow even country lanes to feel capacious don't need expanding. And a driving experience this analogue doesn't need digitising. Through its production run of more than 20 years, the Elise has gone from visionary sports car to left-field alternative to a brand-new classic, crammed full of the involvement and immersion we thought had been left behind. Only with a USB port. And 270hp per tonne...

So while this Elise Cup 250 isn't exactly perfect, so much of it remains timelessly valid to the development and relevance of future sports cars: namely that small, light, simple and clever will nearly always deliver the goods. Many will criticise the price now asked, though it's worth bearing in mind that a 111R's new price of £27,995 in 2004 is now nearly £45k, and that only had 190hp.

Nobody outside the factory quite knows what the future holds for Lotus's sports car range. The manufacturer's ascendance to a more upmarket position seems all but guaranteed (the Evija is nothing if not a £2m statement of intent) and the sustained of success of McLaren - a brand devoted almost solely to the business of building supercars - will not have passed it by. In a perfect world, Lotus would simply splice a sliver more habitability (and dare we say it, desirability) into the Elise's raw talent and - hey presto - everyone's favourite sports car would emerge, fully-formed and 20 per cent cheaper than a Porsche Cayman. But that's not happening, not least for all the reasons that make the Alpine A110 a £50k car and not a £35k one. Better instead to view the 2019 Elise as copper-bottomed proof that, come what may, Lotus still knows where the party is at. Its sheer longevity means that the current generation of Hethel-ites will have grown up with it; as the company grows, a new generation of engineers and technicians must be marched to the track and weaned on it. Welcome to Norfolk, chaps - this is who we are. If Geely is clever enough to let the Elise's shadow loom large over the next twenty years of Lotus car building, it will surely have the kind of rosy future we can all look forward to.


SPECIFICATION - LOTUS ELISE CUP 250
Engine
: 1,798cc, four-cyl supercharged
Transmission: 6-speed manual, rear-wheel drive
Power (hp): 250@7,200rpm
Torque (lb ft): 184@3,500-5,500rpm
0-62mph: 4.3 seconds
Weight: 921kg (unladen, with Carbon Aero pack)
MPG: 37.7 (NEDC combined)
CO2: 175g/km
Price: £49,555

Want one? Search for a Lotus Elise here














 





Author
Discussion

sidesauce

Original Poster:

993 posts

162 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
In before kambites comments.laugh

Riverside Red

860 posts

79 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Enjoyed my 18 months in an Elise S, it was an event every time I drove it, fantastic steering and light weight made it a joy....if only it was easier to get in and out of.

A better drive than my current 981 Boxster by a mile.

RR

SidewaysSi

5,498 posts

178 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
My Elise slaughtered my Cayman GT4 as a driver's car. Forget all that is said about the Porsche, the Lotus killed it at pretty much everything that matters.


rockin

6,697 posts

189 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Three posts in the thread and already two of them are Porsche-bashing.... biggrin

SOL111

625 posts

76 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Always wanted one of these and reckon the cheapest base model is still likely to be awesome.

They hold their money well too. What's not to like (except getting in/out!)

CedricN

459 posts

89 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
It really is a brilliant car !

Its a pity they didnt do a complete redesign/modernization of the interior when the S3 came out, that would probably have helped sales since it would feel more different to older elises, and a bigge reason for existing elise owners to change up. The exterior, drive train and chassis are brilliant already.

janesmith1950

3,496 posts

39 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
I'd love an S1.

kambites

57,204 posts

165 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
They could do whatever they want to the interior and it would still be cramped and relatively awkward to get in and out of. Nothing is going to make a car based on the 111 platform feel modern or mainstream.

I don't see the replacement being anything like the current car. Lightweight may or may not make for "undeniably brilliant sportscars" but it doesn't seem to make for sports cars which sell.

Edited by kambites on Wednesday 7th August 10:05

Composite Guru

1,887 posts

147 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
I moved to a 220 Cup just over 2 years ago due to other performance cars just being too refined and dull to drive.
I love this car to bits and can see me keeping it for some time.
Great performance and so enjoyable to drive. Turns a lot of heads too.

Cold

7,122 posts

34 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
I've got my Lotus bingo card at the ready. A couple of words have already been crossed off, so let's see how long before it's a full house.

Sadly, these days there's little bingo value in "core values", "MX5 rival" or "under £30k" but they'll get a tick anyway. thumbup

TartanPaint

1,361 posts

83 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
I sure hope Lotus stick to their core values and create a new MX5 rival for under £30k.

biggrin

Edit to add something useful to the conversation:

I recently drove an Elise 220 SC (non cup) and I think it was possibly the perfect 2-seater for the road. Nothing squeaked or rattled or knocked or bumped.
The interior felt solid. The steering was still S1-like. Incredible how things have moved on in 20 years, and yet stayed exactly the same.


Edited by TartanPaint on Wednesday 7th August 11:02

Reark

79 posts

32 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Nice write up - even better car.

One day......

Baldchap

1,269 posts

36 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Having bought a 250 Cup in April, I obviously agree with the article that they're excellent.

What rarely gets mentioned is just how good (even in the cup) the ride quality and suspension actually are on normal roads. It doesn't crash into potholes because there isn't the huge weight there that most cars have these days.

flukey5

6 posts

4 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Currently deciding between an Elise sport 220 and a 30th Anniversary MX-5. They're both brilliant in their own ways, I've been procrastinating for weeks.... help

otolith

38,287 posts

148 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Baldchap said:
Having bought a 250 Cup in April, I obviously agree with the article that they're excellent.

What rarely gets mentioned is just how good (even in the cup) the ride quality and suspension actually are on normal roads. It doesn't crash into potholes because there isn't the huge weight there that most cars have these days.
My experience is that you don't feel the pot hole, but because of the lack of noise insulation, it sounds like you left a wheel in it!

Vee12V

818 posts

104 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
flukey5 said:
Currently deciding between an Elise sport 220 and a 30th Anniversary MX-5. They're both brilliant in their own ways, I've been procrastinating for weeks.... help
Depends on how you're going to use it. If it's just the WE toy It's the Elise every time. The MX5 is a bit more friendly as a daily.

john41901

94 posts

10 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Lots Of Trouble Usually Serious smile....

Yep if you want to pretend to be a 'proper' enthusiast on here there are only two car options you can have, this and a Caterham. Utter nonsense of course spouted by clueless idiots.

piers1

587 posts

138 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Having had a 1998 S1, a 2005 111R, which was then supercharged, to a current S3 Exige V6, over 20 years, I agree with all your thoughts.

Nothing else has the tactility of these cars, other than the 570S I was lucky enough to try, a proper grown up Elise/Exige, but a hell of a lot more money, and is it really any faster choosing Europe and into the mountains, possibly, probably not, but I would like to try and compare.

flukey5

6 posts

4 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
Vee12V said:
Depends on how you're going to use it. If it's just the WE toy It's the Elise every time. The MX5 is a bit more friendly as a daily.
Unfortunately it'd have to be a daily, though that's not stopping me convincing myself that I'm flexible enough to put up with it! haha

CanAm

4,563 posts

216 months

Wednesday 7th August
quotequote all
john41901 said:
Lots Of Trouble Usually Serious smile....

Yep if you want to pretend to be a 'proper' enthusiast on here there are only two car options you can have, this and a Caterham. Utter nonsense of course spouted by clueless idiots.
I thought it was MX-5 and of course you have to have an ALFA
before you die.